Somatic Gene Therapy

Somatic Gene therapy is provided by introducing a new therapeutic gene (transgene) into the diseased cells of a patient. The modified cells express the introduced gene and their new phenotype provides some advantage to the patient. For this approach two prerequisites must be worked out:

1. a gene which will benefit the patient and

2. a mechanism or "vector" for introducing that gene into the desired cell types.

The appropriate gene to introduce is obvious for some diseases. For example, cystic fibrosis results from mutations which derange the cftr gene and a logical course is to introduce normal copies of that gene. Finding an appropriate gene for other diseases requires more ingenuity. For example, AIDS researchers are investigating half a dozen very diverse sorts of genes to make cells resistant or inhospitable to HIV infection. The human genome project will help enormously both by making it far easier to identify mutated genes in patients and by revealing the total repertoire of human genes which might be manipulated.

Most gene therapy uses viruses of one sort or another as the vector. The therapeutic gene is inserted into the viral chromosome in place of an essential viral gene. The virus then carries this transgene into the cell it infects. The cell remains viable and expresses the transgene. Of course, the virus must be able to infect the cells to be modified. Some viruses infect only a few cell types. This specificity has certain advantages for genetic engineering. Other viruses infect a broader range of cells and can act as a more general vector, which again is an advantage for some purposes.

The cells easiest to infect are ones that line a surface of tissue, internal or external. They can be directly exposed to viruses. Cystic fibrosis is a good example. One of its major problems is that cells lining the respiratory tract over-produce mucus due to a defective cftr gene. Adenoviruses infect these lining cells. Ideally, patients would merely need to inhale an aerosol of engineered adenoviruses for therapy. Unfortunately, it is not so simple in reality. The efficiency of these vectors in transfering an expressed cftr gene into the target cells leaves much to be desired.

Diseases of deeply buried tissues present an even more formidable challenge. Viruses might be injected into a mass of tissue or the tissue might be removed and its cells dispersed in a test tube, treated with the vector and then reinjected into the body. The latter procedure is called ex-vivo therapy as opposed to in-vivo therapy such as the cystic-fibrosis treatment mentioned.

The first approved somatic gene therapy was in 1990 to treat ADA deficiency (an ex-vivo treatment of white blood cells), and the technology has spread rapidly. In 1996, there were already more than 1500 patients involved in some 230 approved protocols. The original ADA treatment was relatively successful, but the jury is still out on how effective these treatments will prove. Early hype about how rapidly somatic therapy would become a major new avenue to fight disease has led to some disillusionment over the slow pace of its subsequent development. Yet in a few short years much has been accomplished. It is now generally accepted that the main limitations to widespread somatic gene therapy are simply the technical ones of devising effective vectors and transgenes. Most general reservations over safety and philosophical issues have now been satisfied.